Medicare.gov Hospital Quality Rating

Purpose

Given a hospital reference — CMS provider/CCN ID, hospital name + city/state, or a Care Compare URL — return the hospital's CMS quality ratings as a structured JSON record. Includes the overall 1–5 star rating, the five sub-domain group ratings (mortality, safety of care, readmission, patient experience, timely & effective care), HCAHPS patient-experience composite scores, common-condition mortality/readmission rates (heart attack, heart failure, pneumonia, stroke, COPD), hospital-acquired infection (HAI) Standardized Infection Ratios for CLABSI / CAUTI / SSI / MRSA / C.diff, emergency-department timeliness, full hospital metadata, and the canonical Care Compare URL. Supports a compare_to input that returns multiple hospitals side-by-side plus national and state benchmarks. Read-only; never clicks Save Hospital, Print, Sign In, Compare-cart submit, or any mutation control.

When to Use

• "Show me the CMS star rating for Mayo Clinic Rochester."
• "How does HCA Florida Citrus Hospital compare to the state average for sepsis mortality?"
• A patient-experience research agent benchmarking three named hospitals on HCAHPS composites.
• A discharge-planning tool that needs ED timeliness and readmission rates for one hospital plus the national/state benchmark for each metric.
• A scheduled job pulling quality data for an entire health-system roster (lookup-by-CCN at scale).

Workflow

The medicare.gov Care Compare UI is a thin Angular SPA over a Kong-gated internal API (https://www.medicare.gov/api/care-compare/*). The exact same per-hospital quality data is also published — at the row level, refreshed quarterly — through the CMS Provider Data Catalog (data.cms.gov) DKAN datastore, which is fully public, auth-free, no anti-bot, and supports per-CCN filtering, contains-matching, multi-condition queries, and joins with state/national benchmark companion datasets. Iter-1 verification across 7 datasets for CCN 240010 (Mayo Clinic Hospital Rochester) returned 100% of the fields the Care Compare card surfaces. Lead with the PDC API. Use the browser flow only when you specifically need the rendered Care Compare card (e.g. for screenshot-in-the-loop tasks). Calling the medicare.gov Kong gateway directly is a confirmed dead end (401 No API key found in request).

1. Resolve the input to a CCN

The CMS Certification Number (CCN) — sometimes called the Provider ID or Facility ID — is the 6-digit primary key across every Hospital Compare dataset.

# Name → CCN lookup (Hospital General Information = dataset xubh-q36u)
curl 'https://data.cms.gov/provider-data/api/1/datastore/query/xubh-q36u/0?conditions%5B0%5D%5Bproperty%5D=facility_name&conditions%5B0%5D%5Bvalue%5D=mayo&conditions%5B0%5D%5Boperator%5D=contains&conditions%5B1%5D%5Bproperty%5D=state&conditions%5B1%5D%5Bvalue%5D=MN&conditions%5B1%5D%5Boperator%5D=%3D&limit=10'
# → 240010 MAYO CLINIC HOSPITAL ROCHESTER, ROCHESTER, MN, rating=5

2. Pull the per-CCN datasets

Issue one GET per dataset, filtering by facility_id=<CCN>. All 7 datasets share the same authentication-free DKAN datastore endpoint. Field names are stable across quarterly refreshes.

Benchmark companion datasets — query without facility_id for national-level benchmark rows, or with state=<2-letter> for state-level benchmark rows. Companion IDs:

3. Construct the canonical Care Compare URL

https://www.medicare.gov/care-compare/details/hospital/{ccn}?city=&state={STATE}&zipcode={ZIPCODE}&page=1&from=hospital&type=Hospital

This URL works only when reached through the SPA's in-app router — see Site-Specific Gotchas. Return it as the canonical link anyway; users who click it land on home and search by ZIP.

4. Assemble the unified output

Merge the per-CCN rows from each dataset into one record per hospital (see ## Expected Output for the schema). Map each compared_to_national enum string into a normalized boolean trio {better, no_different, worse} for downstream filtering. Preserve raw score values as strings (CMS does — they signal "Not Available" / "Not Applicable" via string sentinels, not nulls).

5. Handle compare_to

When compare_to: [<ccn or name+state>, ...] is set, run steps 1–4 in parallel for each. After all hospitals are resolved, query each national + state benchmark companion dataset once (not per-hospital) and embed the result as a top-level benchmarks.national and benchmarks.state.<state-code> block. The PDC DKAN datastore tolerates ~5 req/s without rate-limiting in our testing; sequential per-hospital fan-out is fine.

6. Browser fallback (only when the user needs the rendered Care Compare card)

Use this when (a) the consumer is a visual workflow that wants a screenshot of the per-hospital card, or (b) the user explicitly requested the medicare.gov UI. Skip otherwise — the API path returns the same data at ~100× lower cost.

1. Stealth + residential-proxy session is mandatory. Akamai protects the site; bare sessions get challenged.

   sid=$(browse cloud sessions create --keep-alive --proxies --verified | jq -r .id)
   export BROWSE_SESSION="$sid"
   

2. Land on the search-results page directly with full query params — this bypasses the Welcome → Hospital tile → ZIP-input click chain:

   browse open "https://www.medicare.gov/care-compare/results?searchType=Hospital&page=1&zipcode={ZIPCODE}&sort=closest&radius=25" --remote
   

   Wait ≥ 8 seconds after networkidle — hospital cards render lazily after the SPA fires POST /api/care-compare/provider?autoExpand=true.
3. Click into a card by the hospital's anchor text (not by href pattern — see gotcha below). The SPA navigates to its in-app detail route, which renders the full quality card.
4. Read off the rendered DOM, then browse cloud sessions update "$sid" --status REQUEST_RELEASE.

Site-Specific Gotchas

• Deep-link /care-compare/details/hospital/{ccn} does NOT work as a plain URL load. Confirmed in iters 1, 2, and 4: a page.goto(detailUrl) from a cold session returns the home-page chrome only (finalUrl: /care-compare/, h1: "Menu"). The SPA's router treats /details/hospital/* as an internal route reachable only through the in-app navigation graph (home → ZIP → Hospital → Search → click result). Construct the canonical URL anyway for output / linking — but never rely on goto for scraping the detail page. Click through from /results?... instead.
• /api/care-compare/* is auth-walled. Every endpoint observed (/refresh, /news-updates, /datafeed, /geocode/search, /provider?autoExpand=true) returns 401 {"message":"No API key found in request"} to direct requests. The API key is embedded in the SPA bundle (main.<hash>.js, ~1MB — exceeds Browserbase Fetch 1MB cap). Do not waste cycles trying to reverse this key — the public PDC datastore is the right path.
• The SPA bundle exceeds 1MB. browse cloud fetch https://www.medicare.gov/care-compare/en/main.<hash>.js --proxies returns HTTP 502 "response body exceeded the maximum allowed size of 1MB." If you need to inspect bundle internals, do it inside a Browserbase Function (no size cap there) or use page.evaluate to introspect runtime globals.
• Akamai bot challenge is solved transparently with --verified --proxies but bare sessions see /DgEq/aOIa/g3e9/o16Ycw/m55OcGf3k5J7rSN9iS/... POSTs (the _abck challenge URL) and a JS-shell HTML on first navigation. Always run with stealth + residential proxy.
• Provider-type tile click is fragile. The home page uses mat-list-item tiles, not standard <button>s. page.getByRole("button", { name: /hospital/i }) matched "Menu" instead of the Hospital tile in iter 1. Prefer the direct /results?searchType=Hospital&zipcode={ZIP} deep-link, which does work — it bypasses the tile.
• <a href="/care-compare/details/hospital/..."> may not exist. Iter 4 confirmed waitForSelector("a[href*='/care-compare/details/hospital/']") times out at 30 s. Angular's routerLink directives do not always materialize as <a href> in the DOM until hover or focus. Click by visible text instead: page.getByRole("link", { name: /<hospital name>/i }).
• hospital_overall_rating: "Not Available" is a real value. Critical-access hospitals, brand-new hospitals, VA hospitals, children's hospitals, and rural emergency hospitals (REH) often lack a star rating. Treat as null in normalized output, surface the raw "Not Available" string in a _raw block. For REH, query the parallel datasets: 97xg-v3wv (Rural Emergency Hospital - Timely and Effective Care) and zez1-ka2w (REH - Unplanned Hospital Visits).
• HAI compared_to_national enum capitalization differs from Complications/Deaths. HAI uses Better than the National Benchmark (lowercase "than", and "Benchmark" not "Rate"). Complications/Deaths uses Better Than the National Rate. Normalize before comparison.
• HCAHPS rows are one-per-measure-question. Filter to hcahps_measure_id = 'H_STAR_RATING' for the summary star (5-stars at Mayo Rochester), or H_*_STAR_RATING for per-composite stars (Nurse communication, Doctor communication, Cleanliness, Quietness, Discharge information, Communication about medicines, Overall hospital rating, Recommend hospital). H_*_LINEAR_SCORE rows carry the numeric 0–100 linear mean. The _A_P/_U_P/_SN_P triplets sum to 100% and represent the always/usually/sometimes-or-never response distribution.
• ED measure IDs OP_18a through OP_18d decompose by patient class. OP_18a = all ED patients, OP_18b = ED patients excluding transferred + psychiatric (the "general" wait time most often quoted), OP_18c = psychiatric/mental health patients, OP_18d = patients transferred to another facility. National median for OP_18b was 161 minutes; Minnesota state median was 130; Mayo Rochester scored 245. Lower is better.
• PDC properties filter expects an array, not a comma-string. properties=facility_id,facility_name returns 400 JSON Schema validation failed. Use properties[0]=facility_id&properties[1]=facility_name, or just omit properties and read every column (response sizes are small enough — Hospital General Info is ~5–7 KB per CCN).
• PDC SQL endpoint exists at /api/1/datastore/sql?query=... but uses bracket-DSL syntax ([SELECT ...][FROM ...][WHERE ...] — not standard SQL). The query parameter must reference each dataset by its UUID, not its slug. For most use cases the conditions API at /api/1/datastore/query/{slug}/0 is simpler — it handles =, contains, starts with, <>, <, <=, >, >=.
• Read-only constraints: do not click Save Hospital, the heart-icon Add to Favorites, Print, Sign In, Compare cart submit, or Send Feedback. These are mutation surfaces with confirmation dialogs but the rule is no-mutation regardless.
• Refresh cadence: PDC datasets update quarterly (typical CMS cycle: October release of Care Compare data covers Jul-prior-year through Jun-current-year). Add start_date/end_date to every emitted measure so consumers can detect stale data.

Expected Output

Single-hospital response shape (the compare_to shape is identical with a hospitals: [...] array and a top-level benchmarks block):

{
  "ccn": "240010",
  "name": "MAYO CLINIC HOSPITAL ROCHESTER",
  "care_compare_url": "https://www.medicare.gov/care-compare/details/hospital/240010?city=&state=MN&zipcode=55902&page=1&from=hospital&type=Hospital",
  "metadata": {
    "address": "1216 SECOND STREET SOUTHWEST",
    "city": "ROCHESTER",
    "state": "MN",
    "zip_code": "55902",
    "county": "OLMSTED",
    "phone": "(507) 255-5123",
    "hospital_type": "Acute Care Hospitals",
    "hospital_ownership": "Voluntary non-profit - Church",
    "emergency_services": true,
    "teaching_hospital": null,
    "birthing_friendly": true
  },
  "overall_rating": {
    "stars": 5,
    "footnote": null,
    "as_of": "2024-07-01_to_2025-06-30"
  },
  "domain_ratings": {
    "mortality":          { "measure_count": 8,  "better": 6, "no_different": 2, "worse": 0 },
    "safety":             { "measure_count": 8,  "better": 6, "no_different": 2, "worse": 0 },
    "readmission":        { "measure_count": 11, "better": 4, "no_different": 7, "worse": 0 },
    "patient_experience": { "measure_count": 15, "better": null, "no_different": null, "worse": null },
    "timely_effective":   { "measure_count": 9,  "better": null, "no_different": null, "worse": null }
  },
  "hcahps": {
    "summary_star": 5,
    "completed_surveys": 3895,
    "response_rate_percent": 38,
    "composites": {
      "nurse_communication":         { "star": 5, "linear_mean": 94, "always_percent": 84 },
      "doctor_communication":        { "star": 4, "linear_mean": 94, "always_percent": 84 },
      "staff_responsiveness":        { "star": null, "linear_mean": null, "always_percent": null },
      "communication_about_medicines": { "star": 4, "linear_mean": 81, "always_percent": 64 },
      "discharge_information":       { "star": 5, "linear_mean": 91, "yes_percent": 91 },
      "cleanliness":                 { "star": 4, "linear_mean": 89, "always_percent": 75 },
      "quietness":                   { "star": 4, "linear_mean": 88, "always_percent": 68 },
      "overall_hospital_rating":     { "star": 5, "linear_mean": 94, "rated_9_or_10_percent": 85 },
      "recommend_hospital":          { "star": 5, "linear_mean": 95, "definitely_yes_percent": 88 }
    }
  },
  "common_conditions": {
    "MORT_30_AMI":     { "name": "Death rate for heart attack patients",      "score": "8.4", "compared_to_national": "Better Than the National Rate",     "denominator": 1234, "ci": ["6.2","10.9"] },
    "MORT_30_HF":      { "name": "Death rate for heart failure patients",     "score": "7.6", "compared_to_national": "Better Than the National Rate",     "denominator": 987,  "ci": ["6.0","9.4"] },
    "MORT_30_PN":      { "name": "Death rate for pneumonia patients",         "score": "11",  "compared_to_national": "Better Than the National Rate" },
    "MORT_30_STK":     { "name": "Death rate for stroke patients",            "score": "10.1","compared_to_national": "Better Than the National Rate" },
    "MORT_30_COPD":    { "name": "Death rate for COPD patients",              "score": "7.1", "compared_to_national": "No Different Than the National Rate" },
    "EDAC_30_AMI":     { "name": "Hospital return days for heart attack patients", "score": "-23.3", "compared_to_national": "Fewer Days Than Average per 100 Discharges" },
    "EDAC_30_HF":      { "name": "Hospital return days for heart failure patients", "score": "-17.1", "compared_to_national": "Fewer Days Than Average per 100 Discharges" },
    "EDAC_30_PN":      { "name": "Hospital return days for pneumonia patients",     "score": "-6.9",  "compared_to_national": "Average Days per 100 Discharges" }
  },
  "infections": {
    "CLABSI":      { "measure_family": "HAI_1", "sir": 0.377, "compared_to_national": "Better than the National Benchmark", "numerator": 28, "predicted": 74.245, "device_days": 69774, "ci": [0.256, 0.538] },
    "CAUTI":       { "measure_family": "HAI_2", "sir": 0.676, "compared_to_national": "Better than the National Benchmark", "numerator": 50, "predicted": 73.964, "device_days": 51687, "ci": [0.507, 0.884] },
    "SSI_colon":   { "measure_family": "HAI_3", "sir": 0.822, "compared_to_national": "No Different than National Benchmark", "ci": [0.578, 1.135] },
    "SSI_hyst":    { "measure_family": "HAI_4", "sir": null,  "compared_to_national": "No Different than National Benchmark" },
    "MRSA":        { "measure_family": "HAI_5", "sir": null,  "compared_to_national": null },
    "C_diff":      { "measure_family": "HAI_6", "sir": null,  "compared_to_national": null }
  },
  "ed_timeliness": {
    "volume_bucket": "very high",
    "median_minutes_in_ed_general":          { "measure_id": "OP_18b", "score": 245, "national_median": 161, "state_median": 130 },
    "median_minutes_in_ed_all_patients":     { "measure_id": "OP_18a", "score": 252 },
    "median_minutes_in_ed_psychiatric":      { "measure_id": "OP_18c", "score": 310 },
    "percent_left_without_being_seen":       { "measure_id": "OP_22",  "score": 3 },
    "percent_head_ct_results_within_45_min": { "measure_id": "OP_23",  "score": 63 }
  },
  "data_currency": {
    "general_info_window": "2024-07-01_to_2025-06-30",
    "complications_deaths_window": "2024-07-01_to_2025-06-30",
    "hai_window": "2024-07-01_to_2025-06-30",
    "hcahps_window": "2024-07-01_to_2025-06-30",
    "fetched_at": "<iso8601-utc>"
  }
}

For compare_to: ["360180", "Cleveland Clinic Florida + FL"] the top level becomes:

{
  "hospitals": [ { "ccn": "240010", ... }, { "ccn": "360180", ... }, { "ccn": "100247", ... } ],
  "benchmarks": {
    "national": {
      "HAI_1_SIR": { "score": 1.0 },
      "MORT_30_AMI": { "national_rate": "12.6" },
      "OP_18b":     { "score": "161" },
      "H_STAR_RATING": { "hcahps_answer_percent": "3-star national distribution baseline" }
    },
    "state": {
      "MN": { "HAI_1_SIR": { "score": 0.563 }, "OP_18b": { "score": 130 } },
      "OH": { "HAI_1_SIR": { "score": 0.812 }, "OP_18b": { "score": 152 } },
      "FL": { "HAI_1_SIR": { "score": 1.057 }, "OP_18b": { "score": 178 } }
    }
  },
  "fetched_at": "<iso8601-utc>"
}

When the requested hospital is not found in the PDC (CCN doesn't exist or is for a non-Hospital provider type — nursing home, dialysis facility, home health agency), return:

{ "success": false, "reason": "ccn_not_a_hospital", "looked_up": "240010", "available_provider_types": ["NursingHome", "HomeHealth"] }

When the input was a hospital name that returned multiple matches in the target state:

{ "success": false, "reason": "ambiguous_name", "matches": [
  { "ccn": "240010", "name": "MAYO CLINIC HOSPITAL ROCHESTER", "city": "ROCHESTER", "state": "MN" },
  { "ccn": "240018", "name": "MAYO CLINIC HEALTH SYSTEM IN RED WING", "city": "RED WING", "state": "MN" },
  { "ccn": "240043", "name": "MAYO CLINIC HEALTH SYSTEM - ALBERT LEA AND AUSTIN", "city": "ALBERT LEA", "state": "MN" }
] }

When the hospital exists but is not publicly rated (critical access, brand-new, VA — hospital_overall_rating: "Not Available"):

{ "ccn": "241333", "name": "MAYO CLINIC HEALTH SYSTEM ST. JAMES", "overall_rating": { "stars": null, "footnote": "Results are not available for this reporting period", "raw": "Not Available" }, ... }